I highly recommend the Vanilla Caramel although if you like coffee I hear the tiramisu is really good!
If you want it check out this deal at Target:
Breyer’s Gelato Indulgences $3.99 (Price Cut ends 2/28)
Use 10% off Breyers Gelato Indulgences on Target Cartwheel
AND $1.00 off ONE Breyers Gelato Indulgences™ product coupon
Final Price: $2.60 (reg $4.49!)