Have you ever tried E.L.F. Cosmetics ? I placed an order with them earlier this year and because of the great prices I was able to grab lots of items in a variety of colors! And right now you can use the code SAVINGSELF to get 50% off your entire purchase up to a $7.50 discount(expires 1/01/11).
Also, if you order through this E.L.F. Cosmetic link you can get a free subscription to Fitness magazine with a purchase of $30 or more! And when you see these prices , you will be amazed how much $30 can get you!